28 September 2004

These mirror Spychips.com pages about which the "mystery clothing company" has made a legal threat demanding their removal.


[Page 1.]

Stop RFID
Protect your privacy - Don't buy items that contain tracking devices!

Home        Overview      Faqs       News Articles       Press Releases       Get Involved
 












RFID PRIVACY ISSUES AND NEWS

What is RFID?



What should be done?
CASPIAN's Proposed Legislation would require labeling on products containing RFID
CASPIAN's Joint Position Statement requests limits on business and government use of RFID



Breaking News

9/23/04
Mystery Clothing Company Plans Item-Level RFID Rollout

CASPIAN obtains photos of Checkpoint's prototype clothing tags


The Spychips website is a project of CASPIAN, Consumers Against Supermarket Privacy Invasion and Numbering. © CASPIAN 2003-2004.


[Page 2.]

Stop RFID
Protect your privacy - Don't buy items that contain tracking devices!

Home        Overview      Faqs       News Articles       Press Releases       Get Involved
 

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
September 23, 2004

MYSTERY CLOTHING COMPANY PLANS ITEM-LEVEL RFID ROLLOUT
CASPIAN obtains photos of prototype clothing tags

An unnamed national company plans to tag all of its clothing items with radio frequency identification (RFID) tracking devices in 2005, according to Checkpoint representatives at last week's Frontline Expo 2004 trade show in Chicago.

Checkpoint is the leader in electronic theft prevention tags and has recently begun encouraging its clients to incorporate RFID in their tagging programs. 

Could the mystery brand be Calvin Klein, Champion, or Abercrombie & Fitch? Representatives from Checkpoint wouldn't say, but based on what we saw, any one of these companies could be toying with the idea. CASPIAN (Consumers Against Supermarket Privacy Invasion and Numbering) obtained clear shots of prototype RFID clothing tags bearing these companies' logos.

[Click here for detailed RFID tag and label photos]

    
[Click here for detailed RFID tag and label photos]

"While Checkpoint didn't reveal the company name, representatives did refer to the company as a ‘well-known national retailer.' That was one clue," said Katherine Albrecht, Founder and Director of CASPIAN. Another clue could be the two prototype dark blue hang tags that "screamed for attention," according to Albrecht.

Albrecht revealed photos that show how Checkpoint attempted to obscure the company brand name on two blue hang tags at their display. Checkpoint representatives reported that the tags contained EPC-compliant RFID chips.

"The manner in which Checkpoint concealed the name leads us to question whether the tape was there to hide the brand name or create drama around the tags," says Albrecht. "Researchers at CASPIAN are pretty good at sniffing out the industry's dirty little secrets, but this was pretty much handed to us on a silver platter. Checkpoint failed to cover over the Abercrombie & Fitch collegiate logo at the end of the tags."

Additional evidence suggesting that Abercrombie & Fitch could be the mystery company comes from a May 18, 2004 Women's Wear Daily article titled "Abercrombie to Give RFID a Try." The article cited statements made by an Abercrombie & Fitch executive at a retail conference earlier this year where he described a new store format that "would be the first in the [Abercrombie & Fitch] group to use RFID at the item level."  

CASPIAN's Albrecht characterizes any plans by Abercrombie & Fitch to roll out item-level RFID tagging as ill-advised. "They're still reeling from boycotts over their marketing practices. It would be a PR disaster for them to further antagonize the public."

Ongoing boycotts of the company were launched by Christian and family oriented organizations, including Focus on the Family, in response to Abercrombie & Fitch's sexually explicit marketing materials. These materials have glorified teen nudity and group sex.

Albrecht offers this parting advice to companies like Abercrombie & Fitch, Calvin Klein, Champion and any other companies considering item-level RFID tagging: "Don't do it. Study what happened to Benetton before taking advice from RFID proponents like Checkpoint. It can be hard to win back customer trust once you've crossed the RFID line."


Consumers Against Supermarket Privacy Invasion and Numbering (CASPIAN) is a grass-roots consumer group fighting retail surveillance schemes since 1999. With thousands of members in all 50 U.S. states and over 30 countries worldwide, CASPIAN seeks to educate consumers about marketing strategies that invade their privacy and to encourage privacy-conscious shopping habits across the retail spectrum.

For more information, see:
http://www.spychips.com and http://www.nocards.org

The Spychips website is a project of CASPIAN, Consumers Against Supermarket Privacy Invasion and Numbering. © CASPIAN 2003-2004.


[Page 3.]

Stop RFID
Protect your privacy - Don't buy items that contain tracking devices!

Home        Overview      Faqs       News Articles       Press Releases       Get Involved
 
The following images supplement a CASPIAN (spychips.com) press release issued September 23, 2004.


Which company has secret,
item-level RFID tagging plans?



"These sure don't look like crate and pallet tags to me."
                                                    - Katherine Albrecht, CASPIAN

closeup
This assortment of clothing tags was on display at the Checkpoint exhibit at an industry conference last week.





At the Frontline Expo 2004 conference last week, Checkpoint revealed that one of their major clothing clients is secretly working on plans to incorporate item-level RFID tags into all of their merchandise in 2005. Could it be Abercrombie & Fitch? Old Navy? Calvin Klein? Carter's? Champion? Apparently the brand doesn't want its RFID involvement publicized; Checkpoint's lips were sealed.

Checkpoint's exhibit promoted "EPC/RFID for retail" for item-level RFID tagging, rather than supply chain or warehouse applications. This puts the company squarely at odds with the recommendations of privacy experts who have called for a moratorium on item-level tagging. No wonder they're keeping mum on their clients' plans.



These two tags Checkpoint RFID tags, masked with black tape, may offer a clue to the "mystery company." They were the only tags in the Checkpoint display which showed an effort to obscure the identity of the company involved. The attempt appears halfhearted, however, since the black tape covering the tags fails to conceal the  "Abercrombie & Fitch" collegiate logo at the lower right.




This label, reading "Checkpoint Systems RFID", was sewn into a Champion athletic wear jacket on display at the Checkpoint exhibit. Champion is owned by Sarah Lee Corporation, one of the earliest companies to invest in the development of EPC/RFID technology.
[For a closeup of the tag, click here
]

Interior view of a Checkpoint RFID clothing label. This is the same type of label that was sewn into the Champion jacket pictured above. [Click here to see a larger view]

An assortment of clothing tags displayed at the Checkpoint exhibit.

The backs of tags displayed at the Checkpoint exhibit.



This Calvin Klein fabric label was among the items featured at the Checkpoint RFID booth. Viewed from the front, it looks looks like an ordinary clothing label that would be sewn into the collar of a shirt or sweater.



Viewed from the back, however, it is apparent that the Calvin Klein clothing label contains a hidden RFID device. The device is only visible when viewed from the back. (Note the metallic antennae extending from either side.)

When the Calvin Klein clothing label is opened, the RFID device it contains can be clearly seen. Note the computer chip in the center of the tag and the metallic antenna extending from it. This chip contains a unique ID number that can be read remotely.

Checkpoint's signage at the trade show promotes the use of RFID tagging on store shelves, yet another violation of the the recommendations of privacy experts concerned about previous and planned abuse of such systems.




The Spychips website is a project of CASPIAN, Consumers Against Supermarket Privacy Invasion and Numbering. © CASPIAN 2003-2004.